Time for Change? Why the EIHL Must Invest in a Proper Challenge Cup Trophy

Photo from EIHL website and is credited to Dean Woolley (We don’t own any rights to this photo and if asked upon this photo may be removed)

On March 12, 2025, the Belfast Giants defeated the Cardiff Devils to win the EIHL Challenge Cup. However, amid the celebrations, an embarrassing incident occurred—one of the Giants' players lifted the trophy, only for it to suddenly break into pieces. The cup simply crumbled apart, through no fault of the player.

The moment quickly went viral, sparking discussion across social media about the quality of the trophy itself. One notable comment came from Fife Flyers’ 2023 emergency backup goalie, Gavin Kelly, who tweeted: “Invest in a proper heritage trophy.” This raises the question: Should the EIHL invest in a better Challenge Cup trophy?

The Importance of a Trophy

Trophies are more than just silverware; they symbolize hard-earned success. Unlike participation medals or certificates, a trophy represents a team’s determination, teamwork, and ability to overcome challenges. A well-crafted, high-quality trophy gives players a sense of pride and respect for the competition’s history, while also serving as a motivating factor for future success.

But what happens when a trophy is cheaply made and falls apart? It risks turning the competition into a joke. Players and fans alike might start to wonder: What’s the point of fighting so hard if all we get is a flimsy plastic cup?

Cost vs. Prestige: Is It Worth the Investment?

There’s no denying that high-end trophies can be expensive. The NHL’s Stanley Cup, for example, is valued at around $23,478 USD. Of course, no one expects the EIHL to match that, but a well-made trophy could still cost hundreds or even thousands of pounds. The question is: Can the league justify the expense?

The EIHL has struggled financially in recent years, facing challenges such as securing TV deals, funding high-quality referees, and attracting major sponsorship. Since Viaplay’s departure, the league has been without a key sponsor, and none appear to be on the horizon. Given these financial constraints, some may argue that spending money on a new trophy isn’t a priority.

Why Is the Challenge Cup Different?

One major question fans have asked is: Why does the league have proper trophies for the league title and playoffs, but not for the Challenge Cup? The short answer is simple—money. The long answer is rooted in history.

During the ISL era, the league had a proper cup with heritage and prestige. However, when the ISL folded, the trophy was gifted to the Nottingham Panthers, leaving the Challenge Cup without a true symbol of its legacy.

This isn’t the first time an EIHL trophy has been an issue. The Gardiner Conference trophy suffered a similar fate when Fife Flyers' Liam Heelis dropped it during their celebrations at the Auld Barn—it broke on impact. A few years later, the conference itself was scrapped in favor of a more competitive league format.

Should the EIHL Make the Investment?

The Challenge Cup is already one of the least popular tournaments in the league, and without meaningful changes, it wouldn’t be surprising to see it disappear altogether. Given the EIHL’s financial struggles, investing in a new trophy could be seen as a waste of money, especially if the competition itself doesn’t survive long-term.

That said, the optics of a crumbling trophy don’t do the league any favors. If the EIHL wants to be taken seriously and improve its reputation, perhaps it’s time to listen to the fans and finally invest in a proper Challenge Cup trophy.

Written by Calan Yule (ENC Owner & Writer)

(c) EIHL News Central

Note:

We are currently looking for writers if you are interested please get in contact via messenger or one of the feedback forms on the website.